Monday, January 30, 2012

Blog Post 1

In the beginning before reading "My Last Duchess" I based the rankings off of what sounded the most correct when looking at a story or in this case a poem.  The order from most important to least:

1. Authorial Intent 
2. Scholarly Context 
3. Traditional Literary Elements
4. Understanding Vocab
5. Modern Cultural Content
6. Contemporary Cultural Content 
7. Personal Beliefs
8. Author's Beliefs

Little did I know that my rankings were not at all accurate.  The step-by-step process changed my outlook on the importance of a poem.  My rankings after reading and analyzing the poem became:
 
1. Authorial Intent =>  You need to understand the text before jumping into it
2. Understanding Vocab =>  It is important to have knowledge of what text is saying in terms of analyzing and/or using criticism 
3. Traditional Literary Elements=>  You should know where the narrator/speaker is going with the text
4. Author's Beliefs=>  You should have an understanding of where the author is coming from
5. Personal Beliefs=>  You can agree or disagree with author while trying to figure out if paradox is resolved 
6. Contemporary Context=>  Understanding the cultural that the story was written about 
7. Modern Cultural Context=>  Compare or Contrast 
8. Scholarly Context=>  See what other authors opinions were

These are what my rankings came out to be after looking at the text a second time.  Once I put them into action I understood what the text was about and was actually able to enjoy it.  I found this poem fun and interesting!  I found myself to be more of an intrinsic critic because I like to look at further meaning of the text instead of just the text itself.  

- Whitney Danley 

My Last Duchess


At the beginning of class I had marked vocabulary, etymology and an understanding of traditional literary elements low on my rankings, but after reading the poem "My Last Duchess," I realized that these were things that were absolutely necessary to being able to understand the work. Also, in the beginning I had ranked author's values and beliefs fairly high on my list, but then later on realized that this was something that did not matter quite as much, especially if I am unable to understand the piece at all.


I believe that I am more of a Reader-response critic, I believe that even though there might be an overall right idea that you should get out of a piece, peoples personal beliefs and experiences will give them individual flavors of that idea, and that is what gives the piece its meaning.


Even though some of my rankings were changed around after reading "My Last Duchess," there were still several that remained the same. I still believe that what the author intended the piece to mean is a big part of the overall meaning to the piece, and that contemporary cultural context can give us clues as to what that intent was. It can be compared to a work of art, an artist creates the work intending to bring light to some part of life or society that they want to bring attention to, and it is then up to the viewer to be able to try and discern what the artist is trying to convey, and to be able to connect and relate to that on a personal level.


I see literature as a form of art, and giving one specific definition to an art piece seems to take away from the mystery of discovery that surrounds art. Although, I can see the appeal of being able to quantify a piece into one specific meaning in a specific way, so as to be able to accurately work with it, and compare it to other works. But that I do not believe this is something that I would gain the most enjoyment out of.


 - Wesley Marin

"My Last Duchess"

When I first read the poem “My Last Duchess,” I found that my literary rankings changes significantly. With all of the flavor that “My Last Duchess” had, it made me feel that I was closest to being  a new historicism more than anything. I focus a lot on the history of the text while keeping in mind the culture and time period the poem would have been written in. With that being said I really liked the poem the second time around. The Duke seemed like a power drunk person while the Duchess just got caught in the middle of his lust. She loved to be down to earth and enjoy life outside of money. While on the hand the Duke Had to have things his way.  Ferrara was a pretty well-known city in Italy at the time.

blog post #1 ( an yu )

( hoping i'm doing this right o.o )

i ranked an understanding of literary elements, contemporary cultural context, and a clear understanding of vocabulary the highest, though i wavered with which order i should place them in. i find it self-explanatory: they seem pretty crucial to analysis and interpretation. i decided that authorial intent and scholarly context (how does what other people think change the meaning of the piece?) didn’t have as big an impact on literary text, because it sounds a little redundant to try and pinpoint what the author may or may not have intended. s/he wrote it. there’s no need to figure out what the author is “trying” to say - s/he already said it, and it should be apparent in the text itself. this ties in with why i ranked authorial beliefs/background lowly, as well. there’s no need to say, “oh, william blake meant to make a point about horrible conditions for child chimney sweepers,” or, “he experienced this as a child himself and that somehow helps me understand the text more.” sure, the fact that tim o’brien was sent to vietnam or that steinbeck lived through the depression definitely prompted them to write in the direction they did, and it’s always interesting to know what the author’s values are, but the information’s not necessary in order to deduce the meaning of the work. i... also don’t quite understand why the reader’s personal beliefs and current culture would have any relevance to analysis. it’ll affect the way we think of the piece, but i feel like that sort of bias wouldn’t be good for analysis. i don't think i'd change any of that after reading "my last duchess."


( lol i just realized now, i’m a harsh lit. critic )


i don’t think i fully understand the idea behind reader-response criticism, as i don’t know how it can ever be considered accurate. this may just be because i’m uncomfortable with getting too close, but mostly i find that there should be a difference between a reader’s personal reaction and the actual criticism. there are a lot of books i can’t get behind because i can’t stand the main character and simply feel no sympathy toward the character’s problems, or i don’t like the way some ideals are illustrated, and though i’d love to express those opinions, i’m not sure if it’d be right. just because i personally see things one way doesn’t mean that’s what the author’s saying, you know? i love arguments made concerning social classes, as they’re usually done really elaborately, and it’s so hard to determine what the right thing is, because there are so many different groups of people with their own goals and dis/advantages. i reckon i’d be interested in feminist criticism as well, though i rarely like the way women are portrayed in literature, but it could definitely make for fun discussions/thoughts/more rambling like this.

Friday, January 27, 2012

First Post for English 201

Hi all,

I'm using the same blog I began last semester (for an English 120 class; the blog was optional). We didn't get very far, but I'd like to develop it much further this time around. While I occasionally post lit and theory-related stories that aren't connected to the class, much of the content is the posts you'll be doing and my comments on them.

Discussion Post 1
 
Discuss your initial rankings of categories and your thoughts following reading "My Last Duchess". Did your rankings change? Why? Why not? Ultimately, what sort of literary critic do you think you are, here at the beginning of the course? (One interested in intrinsic analysis; one looking forward to extrinsic analysis; one anticipating reader-response theory, etc.) You might also discuss any of the following theoretical schools -- do you anticipate you'll be interested in any of them particularly? Why?

Reader-response criticism -- both intrinsic and extrinsic. Concerned, to varying degrees (some do very close text analysis combined with reader response) with how the reader responds personally to a text and why the reader responds as such -- which life experiences, practices, values, etc. inform the reader's response (some analysis of these elements of the reader's life are important). Also: the ideal reader, the "signals" the text sends that "tell" the reader how to read the text (does the reader's response mirror the ideal reader's response? Contradict it?)

Feminist criticism -- both intrinsic and extrinsic. Concerned with female characters authored by men and by women, female authors and their historical and/or biographical information, cultural context (laws, practices, cultural norms for women at the time a text was written and published), whether there's a specific sort of "female" writing that differs from men's writing; how women's bodies are often used as metaphor in texts, etc.

Marxist criticism -- on the whole, concerned primarily with social class -- as it's represented in literature and with the author's class designation/experience.  Concerned with issues of alienation and fragmentation caused by low-level work, rebellion and revolution, how the upper class creates and influences most ideas and practices that circulate through culture.

***Please title this "Blog Post 1" and make sure your name appears somewhere in the post. Sometimes people use blog handles that don't clarify their name -- we need to know you are.

***Be sure to respond to at least one other posting (and this response needs to go beyond "good job!" or "I agree!" Students often disagree with one another (in my experience) but usually handle things very diplomatically. Ask questions, offer alternative ideas, explain WHY you agree on a personal issue, etc. Response posting is part of the point total for each post.

Saturday, December 3, 2011

What I'm Reading . . . (Besides Papers and Discussion Posts)

Rick Moody, The Four Fingers of Death (predominantly sci-fi, outrageous plot). I'm not that into sci-fi, but this is surprising me. It's a lot of fun. I'm part of a book club of exactly two, and this was my friend Joseph's Voth's pick, so here and I am with this 700-page novel. (It's possible you've had Voth since he taught at MCC for a long time).

Joan Didion, Blue Nights (absolutely one of my favorite essayists; this chronicles the death of the beloved writer's only child, daughter Quintana) Didion wrote The Year of Magical Thinking about her husband's sudden death (he died shortly after Quintana fell ill . . . she is now 76, bereaved of both beloved husband and daughter).

Just finished: Jeffrey Eugenides' The Marriage Plot (it follows Brown English major Madeline's academic trajectory as she deals with the "marriage plot" as it's been conceived in fiction thus far and her romantic relationships). I liked, didn't love this -- it's hardly his breathtaking-in-scope Middlesex: ""I was born twice: first, as a baby girl, on a remarkably smogless Detroit day of January 1960; and then again, as a teenage boy, in an emergency room near Petoskey, Michigan, in August of l974. . . My birth certificate lists my name as Calliope Helen Stephanides. My most recent driver’s license...records my first name simply as Cal."  Eugenides also write the best-known The Virgin Suicides, which was made into a film starring Kirsten Dunst.

I also finished Jonathan Franzen's epic Freedom. I loved this on so many levels. Definitely worth a read. He's fabulous at chronicling modern suburban ennui and family dynamics.

Tuesday, November 29, 2011

Want Free Books?

You can get quite a few classics on Google books for free. You download them; they're yours. You can read them on a Kindle, a Nook, a tablet, or your computer. Go here

Not a bad deal.


You might try this one as well -- lots of titles.